garden state: movie I wish I had never watched again

Zach Braff, Natalie Portman, Peter Sarsgaard in Garden State

So Garden State was probably easily in my top 10 favorite movies from ages 14 to 16. I mean I discovered the Shins because of this movie [like the rest of the mainstream world.] It slowly fell in favor of older movies that I was discovering, but I think thought I enjoyed it. Over winter break, I had an indie film fest with my mom, watching this and (500) Days of Summer, which I love, and I was sorely disappointed by it.

I originally loved this movie because I felt it showed how bipolar and bipolar medicine can affect a man and his familial connections, as well as his attempts at love.

But I was so disappointed by the maudlin interpretation of life that I held up so highly in earlier years. Zach Braff’s character  is just really annoying and kind of pretentious, and it spreads with his directing. And now I can’t look back fondly on the movie.

I hate the idea that mental health problems can be fixed by another person. Watching this movie again made me realize how warped my perception of what mental health recovery looked like at age 15.

The two parts I felt were the saving grace were Peter Sarsgaard and the soundtrack. Peter is wonderful and captured completely every character he plays. Did you see him be suave and debonair in The Education? I didn’t even recognize him at first, but he was wonderful and very convincing, just like he was in Garden State. And the soundtrack had Coldplay, The Shins, Frou Frou, Simon and Garfunkel and Iron & Wine, all that I love.

I am eternally grateful to Zach Braff and this movie though, because it introduced me to a relatively indie band, The Shins, which expanded my then musical tastes beyond Maroon 5, George Gershwin and whatever was on the radio.


Filed under Film, Music

3 responses to “garden state: movie I wish I had never watched again

  1. I saw Garden State for the first time about 3 years ago, and I had kind of the same reaction. I’d actually discovered The Shins through a friend who’d seen the movie, so I can’t pin my music tastes on this movie directly. I went in really wanting to like the movie. The friends I watched it with were kind of obsessed with it, actually. But I just couldn’t enjoy it, for various reasons. I think your critique really hit the nail on the head. I feel like if I watched it again I’d have a clearer idea of what it was supposed to accomplish, but as it is, it just left me feeling kind of empty. And really, who wants to watch a movie that does that?

  2. Basically, Garden State is a great film for anybody who likes feel-good romantic dramedies. That hit the core of the heart the right way. It makes you think about life, as well as makes you laugh about it, and just possibly have you thinking differently about it.

  3. Pingback: In defense of Susan, Summer and Cassie | miss woodhouse goes to college

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s